Quality, Expert-Derived Cybersecurity Documentation To Keep Organizations Secure, Compliant & Resilient  |  Got Questions? +1-307-241-8740
ComplianceForge

How Do You Comply With NY DFS 23 NYCRR 500.5 Vulnerability Management?

Short Answer

23 NYCRR 500.5 requires written, risk-based vulnerability management policies and procedures that ensure annual penetration testing from inside and outside the system boundaries by a qualified party, automated scans plus manual review of systems the scans miss at a risk-based frequency and after material changes, a monitoring process for new vulnerabilities, and timely, risk-prioritized remediation.

23 NYCRR 500.5 Vulnerability Management at a Glance

  • Regulation: NY DFS Cybersecurity Requirements for Financial Services Companies, 23 NYCRR Part 500.
  • Section: 23 NYCRR 500.5 Vulnerability Management.
  • Status: Amended by the Second Amendment, effective November 1, 2023.
  • Who it applies to: Every covered entity that does not qualify for an exemption under 500.19(a), (c) or (d).
  • Class A companies: None beyond the general requirement.
  • Limited exemption (500.19(a)): Exempt. 500.19(a) limited-exemption entities do not need to meet 500.5.
  • Compliance dates: Most new requirements applied from April 29, 2024 (500.22(c)). The automated scan and manual review requirement in 500.5(a)(2) applied from May 1, 2025, 18 months after the effective date (500.22(d)(3)).

The Second Amendment retitled 500.5 from Penetration Testing and Vulnerability Assessments to Vulnerability Management. The old option of continuous monitoring in place of testing is gone, and so is the bi-annual vulnerability assessment.

What remains is a minimum testing program written into policies and procedures: annual penetration testing from both inside and outside the boundaries, risk-based automated scanning with manual review where scans do not reach, a process to learn about new vulnerabilities promptly, and remediation prioritized by risk.

What Does 23 NYCRR 500.5 Require?

The following is the text of 23 NYCRR 500.5 Vulnerability Management as amended by the Second Amendment to Part 500, effective November 1, 2023. Only the formatting has been adjusted for readability.

  • Each covered entity shall, in accordance with its risk assessment, develop and implement written policies and procedures for vulnerability management that are designed to assess and maintain the effectiveness of its cybersecurity program. These policies and procedures shall be designed to ensure that covered entities:
  • (a) conduct, at a minimum:
  • (1) penetration testing of their information systems from both inside and outside the information systems’ boundaries by a qualified internal or external party at least annually; and
  • (2) automated scans of information systems, and a manual review of systems not covered by such scans, for the purpose of discovering, analyzing and reporting vulnerabilities at a frequency determined by the risk assessment, and promptly after any material system changes;
  • (b) are promptly informed of new security vulnerabilities by having a monitoring process in place; and
  • (c) timely remediate vulnerabilities, giving priority to vulnerabilities based on the risk they pose to the covered entity.

Source: NY DFS, Second Amendment to 23 NYCRR 500 (text).

How Does 23 NYCRR 500.5 Map to the Secure Controls Framework (SCF)?

The SCF publishes a NIST IR 8477 Set Theory Relationship Mapping (STRM) between 23 NYCRR Part 500 (2023 Amendment 2) and SCF version 2026.3. It maps 23 NYCRR 500.5 to 9 SCF controls through 9 relationships (1 "subset of", 8 "intersects with").

How to read the mapping: each relationship runs from the Part 500 text to the SCF control. "Subset of" means the Part 500 requirement is fully contained within the SCF control. "Intersects with" means the Part 500 requirement and the SCF control share partial overlap. The strength of relationship runs from 1 (nominal) to 10 (strongest), where 5 is moderately strong and 10 is typically reserved for "equal" and "subset of" relationships.

  • GOV-04 Publishing Security, Compliance & Resilience Documentation. Subset of (strength 10): 500.5. SCF control: Mechanisms exist to establish, maintain and disseminate policies, standards and procedures necessary for secure, compliant and resilient capabilities.
  • VPM-02 Vulnerability & Patch Management Program (VPMP). Intersects with (strength 8): 500.5. SCF control: Mechanisms exist to facilitate the implementation and monitoring of risk-based vulnerability management capabilities.
  • VPM-18 Penetration Testing. Intersects with (strength 8): 500.5(a)(1). SCF control: Mechanisms exist to conduct penetration testing on Technology Assets, Applications and/or Services (TAAS).
  • VPM-12 Vulnerability Scanning. Intersects with (strength 8): 500.5(a)(2). SCF control: Mechanisms exist to detect vulnerabilities and configuration errors by routine vulnerability scanning of systems and applications.
  • VPM-03 Attack Surface Scope. Intersects with (strength 5): 500.5(a)(1). SCF control: Mechanisms exist to define and manage the scope for its attack surface management activities.
  • VPM-06.2 Continuous Vulnerability Remediation Activities. Intersects with (strength 5): 500.5(b). SCF control: Mechanisms exist to address new threats and vulnerabilities on an ongoing basis and ensure assets are protected against known attacks.
  • VPM-04 Vulnerability Exploitation Analysis. Intersects with (strength 5): 500.5(c). SCF control: Mechanisms exist to identify, assess, prioritize and document the potential impact(s) and likelihood(s) of applicable internal and external threats exploiting known vulnerabilities.
  • VPM-05 Vulnerability Ranking. Intersects with (strength 5): 500.5(c). SCF control: Mechanisms exist to identify and assign a risk ranking to newly discovered security vulnerabilities using reputable outside sources for security vulnerability information.
  • VPM-06 Vulnerability Remediation Process. Intersects with (strength 5): 500.5(c). SCF control: Mechanisms exist to ensure that vulnerabilities are properly identified, tracked and remediated.

The STRM records "no relationship" for the lead-in text of 500.5(a); the numbered paragraphs under it are mapped individually.

Mapping taken from the STRM published with SCF version 2026.3. Download it at no cost: SCF STRM for NY DFS 23 NYCRR 500 (2023 Amendment 2). The SCF explains the method in its Set Theory Relationship Mapping (STRM) guidance.

Common Pitfalls With 23 NYCRR 500.5

The following are issues teams commonly run into, not certainties. Each one is tied to the text of the regulation:

  • External-only penetration tests. 500.5(a)(1) requires testing from both inside and outside the information systems' boundaries, at least annually, by a qualified internal or external party.
  • Scan gaps. 500.5(a)(2) requires a manual review of systems not covered by automated scans. An asset list that does not match the scan scope leaves this unmet.
  • No rescans after major changes. Scans are also required promptly after any material system change, not just on the regular schedule.
  • Remediation without risk priority. 500.5(c) requires timely remediation that gives priority to vulnerabilities based on the risk they pose. Document the prioritization method and the timelines.

What Is Reasonable Evidence for 23 NYCRR 500.5?

NY DFS does not publish a fixed evidence list. Under 500.17(b)(3), records supporting the annual certification or acknowledgment must be kept for five years.

The SCF Evidence Request List (ERL) ties evidence artifacts to SCF controls. ERL items linked to the SCF controls mapped to 23 NYCRR 500.5 include:

  • E-GOV-01.33 Vulnerability & Patch Management Policy. Documented evidence of a vulnerability and patch management policy.
  • E-GOV-02 Cybersecurity & Data Protection Standards. Documented evidence of an appropriately-scoped cybersecurity & data protection standards. Standards are mandatory requirements regarding processes, actions and configurations. Standards are intended to be granular and prescriptive to ensure Technology Assets, Applications and/or Services (TAAS) are designed and operated to include appropriate cybersecurity & data protection protections
  • E-GOV-04 Cybersecurity & Data Protection Procedures. Documented evidence of an appropriate appropriately-scoped cybersecurity & data protection procedures. Procedures are a documented set of steps necessary to perform a specific task or process in conformance with an applicable standard. Procedures help address the question of how the organization actually operationalizes a policy, standard or control. The result of a procedure is intended to satisfy a specific control. Procedures are also commonly referred to as “control activities.”
  • E-VPM-01 Vulnerability & Patch Management Program (VPMP). Documented evidence of a Vulnerability & Patch Management Program (VPMP). This is program-level documentation in the form of a runbook, playbook or a similar format provides guidance on organizational practices that support existing policies and standards.
  • E-VPM-02 Penetration Testing - Application. Documented evidence of Application Security Testing (AST) activities: Abuse case, malformed, and unexpected inputs (e.g., Robustness or Fuzz testing); Attack surface analysis; Vulnerability chaining; Closed box testing of known vulnerability scanning; Software composition analysis of binary executable files; and/or Static and dynamic code analysis, including testing for credentials that are “hardcoded,” default, easily guessed, and easily compromised.
  • E-VPM-03 Penetration Testing - Network. Documented evidence of internal and external network penetration testing activities that focus on discovering and exploiting security vulnerabilities.
  • E-VPM-11 Vulnerability Scanning. Documented evidence of internal and external vulnerability scans being performed.
  • E-VPM-10 Applicable Flaws & Vulnerabilities. Documented evidence of flaws and vulnerabilities potentially affecting a specific system, application and/or service.

Records specific to 23 NYCRR 500.5 that typically show the requirement is designed and operating:

  • Vulnerability management policy and procedures. Written documents covering testing, scanning, monitoring and remediation.
  • Penetration test reports. Annual reports showing internal and external testing, the tester's qualifications and the findings.
  • Scan schedule and results. Scan frequency set by the risk assessment, scan reports, and records of manual review for systems not scanned.
  • Change-triggered scans. Records linking material system changes to follow-up scans.
  • Remediation tracking. Tickets or a register showing priority, target dates and closure.

Which ComplianceForge Documents Support 23 NYCRR 500.5?

The following ComplianceForge documents can help you document and implement 23 NYCRR 500.5 Vulnerability Management:

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How often does 23 NYCRR 500.5 require penetration testing? At least annually. The testing must cover the information systems from both inside and outside their boundaries and must be done by a qualified internal or external party.

How often must covered entities run vulnerability scans under 500.5? At a frequency determined by the risk assessment, and promptly after any material system changes. Systems that automated scans do not cover need a manual review.

Does continuous monitoring still replace penetration testing under 500.5? No. The Second Amendment removed the continuous monitoring alternative. The amended section sets annual penetration testing and risk-based automated scans as minimums.

Do small entities with a limited exemption need to meet 500.5? No. 500.5 is one of the sections waived for entities that qualify for the 500.19(a) limited exemption.

Bottom Line on 23 NYCRR 500.5 Vulnerability Management

500.5 now sets testing minimums rather than options. Write the vulnerability management policy, test inside and out every year, match scan scope to the asset inventory with manual review for the gaps, rescan after material changes, and keep a risk-ranked remediation record.

Authoritative sources:

This page reproduces New York State regulatory text from 23 NYCRR Part 500. It is educational, not legal advice. Last reviewed: 2026-11-15.

Other 23 NYCRR Part 500 Requirements

Previous section: 500.4 Cybersecurity Governance. Next section: 500.6 Audit Trail. Sections 500.0, 500.18, 500.21, 500.23 and 500.24 are covered in the NY DFS 23 NYCRR Part 500 Compliance Guide.